The Humane League Evaluation Supplement
Theory of Change Table
Yellow highlight = priority path to impact as identified by ACE in collaboration with THL
| Program | Program expenses (% total expenditures) |
Program description | Activities (what THL does to create change) |
Early outcomes (the change in behavior, knowledge, or attitudes that results from THL’s activities) |
Intermediate outcomes (the results that follow from THL’s early outcomes) |
Final outcomes (the final steps that need to happen for THL to have their desired impact) |
Impact (the ultimate change THL is trying to achieve) |
| Cage-Free Accountability Campaigns (Global, U.S., and U.K.) | Global Cage-Free Campaigns (11%) |
THL persuades companies globally to report their progress toward their cage-free commitments to ensure that they are fulfilling them. They also pressure companies that have taken down their commitments to republish them, and encourage companies – where possible – to meet their cage-free goals ahead of schedule. | Engage in direct dialogue with companies to persuade them to report progress on their cage-free commitments | Companies respond to THL’s emails and meeting requests.
Companies report on their commitments, wholly or partially. Companies seek information about suppliers and work with THL to identify solutions in challenging markets. |
Companies fulfill their commitments in established cage-free markets (where supply is more readily available). | Companies fulfill their global commitments, including in emerging markets.
Major producers across the world introduce or scale up cage-free production. Global commitments are used as leverage by local groups to influence national companies, which are the largest egg users. |
Improved welfare for farmed chickens |
| Companies make meaningful progress towards fulfilling their commitments.
Companies meet with organizations like Humane World, Compassion in World Farming, or Global Food Partners for transition support. |
|||||||
| Lead public pressure campaigns to persuade companies to meet their cage-free commitments (e.g., through social media and protests) | Companies understand that failure to take meaningful action will result in increased campaign pressure.
Targeted companies take some steps in the right direction. This can include: reaffirming their commitment, but with a caveat or unreasonable timeline; or publishing limited reporting data. |
Companies fulfill their global commitments, including in emerging markets.
Global commitments are used as leverage by local groups to influence national companies, which are the largest egg users. THL maintains a reputation as a strong pressure alliance so that the threat of a campaign carries significant weight. |
|||||
| Publish reports and global rankings of companies to highlight those who are failing to meet their cage-free commitments | Prior to publication, companies express concern about the upcoming report and become increasingly responsive as the deadline approaches.
Prior to publication, the snippet view of the report shared with relevant companies elicits reactions (many opens, immediate requests from the company to meet with THL, companies immediately deciding to share some data with THL when they had previously been unwilling). Post-publication, international media cover THL’s reports, including call-outs of companies that are and are not reporting on their cage-free progress. Post-publication, previously unresponsive companies engage with THL. Post-publication, companies respond to THL’s emails and meeting requests; meetings are productive. |
Companies take meaningful action towards fulfilling their commitments.
The report is well respected by companies, media outlets, and other key audiences. The report stirs up a sense of competition among companies in the same sector. |
Companies fulfill their global commitments, including in emerging markets.
THL maintains a positive public narrative about cage-free transitions, highlighting the success of many companies and the failure of just a few. THL is seen by the media as a credible source of information on corporate accountability and animal welfare. Global commitments are used as leverage by local groups to influence national companies, which are the largest egg users. |
||||
| US Cage-Free Accountability (23%) | THL persuades companies in the U.S. to report their progress toward their cage-free commitments to ensure that they are fulfilling them. They also pressure companies that have taken down their commitments to republish them, and encourage companies, where possible, to meet their cage-free goals ahead of schedule. | Engage in direct dialogue with companies to persuade them to report progress on their cage-free commitments | Companies respond to THL’s emails and meeting requests; meetings are productive.
Companies report on their commitments, wholly or partially. Companies seek information about suppliers and work with THL to identify solutions. |
Companies make and report meaningful progress towards fulfilling their commitments. This can include: reporting on their commitments and sharing a progress percentage; sharing roadmaps to outline how and when they will make progress; (for retailers) committing to time-bound steps to shift consumer egg purchases to a higher proportion of cage-free eggs; or publicly reaffirming their commitment. | Companies fulfill their commitments.
Major producers scale up cage-free production. |
||
| Lead public pressure campaigns to persuade companies to meet their cage-free commitments (through corporate and executive targeting). This activity covers pressure tactics that do not involve THL’s supporters or direct dialogue and includes activities such as publishing websites and advertisements targeting individual executives, putting pressure on affiliations of executives, and the use of billboards or other materials highlighting the company’s failure to fulfill or report progress on their commitments. | Companies understand that failure to take meaningful action will result in campaign pressure.
Targeted companies take some steps in the right direction. |
Companies make and report meaningful progress towards fulfilling their commitments. | Companies fulfill their commitments.
Major producers scale up cage-free production. THL maintains a reputation as a strong pressure alliance so that the threat of a campaign carries significant weight. |
||||
| Organize THL volunteers and mobilize consumers to pressure companies to meet their cage-free commitments (e.g., through social media and protests) | More supporters take more direct campaign actions.
Top volunteers build and strengthen local action teams to take more direct campaign actions. Target companies feel direct pressure from campaign actions and engage in dialogue with THL. |
Executives at target companies feel ongoing pressure, leading to negotiation with THL.
THL builds power for their campaigns and their mission by inspiring more campaign actions, while also growing the base of supporters who fuel their work in the short- and long-term. Local action teams build power locally and escalate campaign actions nationwide and at target company headquarters. |
Companies fulfill their commitments.
Local action teams learn from and apply skills to build power and innovate to take direct action against other target companies. |
||||
| Publish reports and rankings of companies to highlight those who are failing to meet their cage-free commitments | Prior to publication, companies express concern about the upcoming report and become increasingly responsive as the deadline approaches.
Prior to publication, the snippet view of the report shared with relevant companies elicits reactions (many opens, immediate requests from the company to meet with THL, companies immediately deciding to share some data with THL when they had previously been unwilling). Post-publication, previously unresponsive companies engage with THL. Post-publication, companies respond to THL’s emails and meeting requests; meetings are productive. Post-publication, national and local media cover THL’s reports, including call-outs of companies who are and are not reporting on their cage-free progress. |
Targeted companies take meaningful action towards fulfilling their commitments (see three rows above for examples of meaningful progress).
The report is well respected by companies, media outlets, and other key audiences. The report stirs up a sense of competition among companies of the same sector. |
Companies fulfill their commitments.
THL maintains a positive public narrative about cage-free transitions, highlighting the success of many companies and the failure of just a few. THL is seen by the media as a credible source of information on corporate accountability and animal welfare. |
||||
| UK Cage Free Accountability (0.3%) | THL UK works to hold U.K. companies accountable by urging them to publicly report progress toward their 2025 cage-free commitments, ensuring those promises are being kept. Where feasible, they also encourage companies to accelerate their timelines and transition to cage-free systems ahead of schedule.
When companies remove or backtrack on their pledges, THL UK applies pressure to have those commitments reinstated. |
Engage in direct dialogue with companies to persuade them to report progress on their cage-free commitments | Companies respond to THL UKs emails and meeting requests; meetings are productive.
Companies report on their commitments, wholly or partially. Companies seek information about suppliers and work with THL UK and other NGOs to identify solutions. |
THL uses industry insights to track progress, identify future campaign targets, and maintain pressure on those companies to fulfill their commitments.
Companies report any significant progress they have made, including meeting commitments in advance of the deadline, encouraging others in the industry to do the same. |
Companies fulfill their commitments.
Cage-free becomes the U.K. standard. |
||
| UK Cages Policy Program | 0.6% | THL UK lobbies the government to bring about a full legislative ban on cages for laying hens.
Public pressure and communication tactics are launched at strategic times. |
Strengthen relationships with key political allies and government decision-makers | THL UK builds trust with major decision-makers and establishes and engages in regular communication with them. | The number of political allies publicly vocalizing their support for banning cages increases.
The Scottish Government publishes the results from their consultation on phasing out cages for laying hens |
Public and political outcry against cages for laying hens reaches a climax and the government is forced to act.
The use of cages for laying hens is outlawed in UK law, setting the gold standard for other countries to follow. |
|
| Regular collaboration with three NGOs (CIWF, RSPCA and Animal Policy International) that focus on cages, working together to bring about legislative change. | THL UK works with other NGOs to maintain consistent pressure on key decision-makers.
THL UK maintains public awareness of the ongoing use of cages for laying hens. |
||||||
| Open Wing Alliance Grant Program | 15% | The Open Wing Alliance Grant Program funds member organizations to run institutional campaigns to obtain cage-free commitments for laying hens and obtain broiler welfare commitments that meet or exceed the Better Chicken Commitment, particularly for new and emerging organizations in underfunded regions. | Identify, review, and select high-impact grant proposals from OWA member organizations. This is followed by monitoring and evaluating grantee progress through regular reporting, check-ins and performance assessments. | Grantee organizations can begin or continue their institutional campaigns.
Grantees improve their strategic direction and knowledge of effective institutional advocacy approaches, improving the impact of their campaigns. Grantees have improved capacity to measure campaign progress and outcomes. Grantees feel supported and motivated to expand their campaign efforts. |
More OWA member organizations initiate or scale up cage-free or broiler welfare campaigns, engaging more companies and stakeholders in a more coordinated, data-driven, and outcome-focused way.
There is a greater commitment from OWA member organizations to long-term animal welfare advocacy. |
More companies publicly commit to cage-free and broiler welfare standards, including some of the biggest egg/broiler meat users in OWA members’ countries and regions.
There is increased corporate transparency and accountability on commitment progress. More campaigns reach a national or regional scale, influencing market trends. Institutional support for higher-welfare standards becomes normalized globally. |
|
| Disburse grants to support institutional cage-free and broiler welfare campaigns likely to have a high impact. | |||||||
| Provide strategic feedback and support to funded organizations. | |||||||
| Hold regional summits that bring OWA members together to share tactics, support and successes. | OWA groups around the world have increased knowledge of corporate engagement work.
OWA groups overcome initial corporate engagement barriers (such as emails being ignored) and enter into active dialogue with companies. OWA groups have increased motivation for pressure campaigns, including in countries where this is particularly challenging. There is better join-up of animal activists at a national, regional, and global level. |
OWA groups secure local and regional cage-free commitments.
OWA groups leverage global and local wins. This creates a ‘domino effect’ of companies committing to cage-free or improved broiler standards, based on tactics like targeting competitors and using ranking reports. |
OWA groups secure large commitments that impact up to hundreds of thousands of hens around the world, normalizing cage-free and improved broiler welfare standards.
Skilled and experienced OWA groups support and train newer groups in the movement. Movement-building work equips groups around the world to be stronger activists for animals now and into the future, potentially outlasting the OWA. |
||||
| Maintain a highly active Slack platform, with 600+ individual OWA members seeking/giving support, sharing victories, and strategizing. | |||||||
| Align and empower OWA member organizations, including contextualizing OWA strategies to their local contexts, through regular regional and sub-regional calls and tailored individual support. | |||||||
| US Public Policy Work | 3% | THL works in coalition with other organizations to pass and defend cage-free laws against threats such as the Ending Agricultural Trade Suppression (EATS) Act, which would undo all state-level bans on the sale of animal products involving specific unethical practices (such as the use of caged hens). | Build and collaborate with a coalition of organizations to oppose federal legislation that could harm animal interests (e.g., the EATS Act). | Policymakers, particularly in Congress, are more informed about the risks of federal preemption and become increasingly unwilling to support EATS-like legislation.
THL’s grassroots base becomes more activated and engaged in state and federal policy processes. Changemakers and allied advocates gain skills and confidence in public policy advocacy. |
More Members of Congress become more actively opposed to any legislation, such as the EATS Act.
State laws banning the sale of caged eggs and other cruel farmed animal products remain intact. |
The new Farm Bill passes with no language in it that undoes state laws.
THL defeats any further attempts to repeal state cage-free laws. Additional states (e.g., Maryland, Illinois) pass and implement cage-free legislation, building momentum towards more state cage-free laws. |
|
| Send multiple action alerts to supporters to support campaigns (e.g., keeping EATS out of the Farm Bill). | |||||||
| Provide training to changemakers on writing letters to the editor and lobbying on relevant legislation (e.g., the Farm Bill), including through an action toolkit aimed at changemakers and Animal Policy Alliance members. | |||||||
| Support coalition led by Humane World for Animals to pass and protect cage-free legislation in specific states. | |||||||
| Engage in direct staff outreach to Congressional offices urging them not to support legislation that could harm animal interests (e.g., EATS-like language in the Farm Bill). | |||||||
| UK + EU Better Chicken Commitment (BCC) Program | 7% | THL UK works to secure, and retain, corporate welfare commitments which improve the lives of broilers, in line with the Better Chicken Commitment. The program includes pressuring new companies to sign up to new commitments, as well as pressuring corporates with existing commitments to report on their progress. | Continue engagement and pressure through communications and in-person meetings with companies | Companies respond to THL’s emails and meeting requests.
Companies feel held accountable to report on their commitments, wholly or partially. Companies understand that failure to take meaningful action will result in campaign pressure. Companies seek information about suppliers, working with THL and other NGOs to identify solutions in challenging markets. Previously unresponsive companies engage with THL. |
Demand for BCC-compliant chicken increases, with producers and breeders engaging in productive conversations.
Pressure builds for companies to generate breed change roadmaps. An increasing number of committed U.K. companies publicly report progress towards their commitment deadline. |
All U.K. supermarkets, then all major companies and chains, commit to the full BCC, with realistic roadmaps for breed change.
All U.K. companies with existing commitments are reporting progress with clear roadmaps and deadlines. The general public supports the move to slower-growing breeds. Corporations around the world see this early adoption of the BCC in the U.K., giving credibility to the business case for change in other countries. The BCC becomes the new baseline standard for farming. |
|
| Lead public pressure and media campaigns to persuade U.K. supermarkets to sign up to the BCC (e.g., through social media, mobilisation of THL supporters and volunteers, street protests, etc), bringing in the support of Europe-based OWA groups as needed. | Target companies feel direct pressure to take steps towards BCC implementation and engage in, or continue to engage in, dialogue with THL UK.
Other retailers are influenced by the heightened scrutiny being given to their competitors, and accelerate their own progress towards the BCC. |
||||||
| US Animal Policy Alliance Program | 4% | The Animal Policy Alliance (APA) equips, connects and empowers local and state-level animal advocacy groups across the US that are involved in implementing legislative strategies for farmed animals. | Provide research, legislative drafting, and campaign strategy support for APA member legislative campaigns for farmed animals. | The APA has built an alliance of over a dozen local and state-level animal protection groups across the U.S.
APA member organizations have the capacity, funding, organizational structures, tools, and knowledge to conduct or engage in public policy campaigns, with a focus on passing plant-based policies and bans on certain animal products. More individuals engage in APA member groups’ campaigns and in unrepresented areas. Relationships with legislators at the local, state, and federal level grow substantially in quality and quantity. Additional new policies are passed. |
The APA covers half of the states in the US and includes new groups working to pass policies to address large-scale animal cruelty.
More individuals take action in APA communities/states. More leaders join the movement and recruit others to take action. Most legislators no longer support many initiatives introduced by the factory farming industry, and instead support pro-animal legislation. More APA member organizations initiate or scale up public policy campaigns for farmed animals at the state and local level, and sometimes federally. |
There are APA member groups in all 50 states that are powerful players in their local and state-level governments, and collectively the APA is powerful at the federal level.
A critical mass of advocates take action by advocating to protect farmed animals through public policy. Legislation is routinely passed or defeated at all levels of government in the U.S. to protect animals raised for food. The farmed animal protection movement outmatches the animal agriculture lobbying groups in Congress and in state and local governments in the U.S. The factory farming system can no longer sustain itself in the U.S. without its ability to influence public policy in its favor. Society in the U.S. shifts away from systemically abusing animals raised for food, and plant-based diets become far more common. |
Far fewer animals are farmed for food.
The farmed animals that remain experience significantly better welfare. |
| Engage THL’s supporter base in APA member campaigns | |||||||
| Recruit and onboard new APA member organizations | |||||||
| Equip APA members with resources and connection opportunities via an annual APA summit, monthly APA calls, and the APA website. | |||||||
| Award grants to APA member organizations to run policy campaigns to achieve public wins for farmed animals that have both direct impact and movement power-building impact. | |||||||
| UK Fish Policy Program | 0.7% | THL UK works to embed species-specific slaughter legislation for fishes across the U.K., giving them the same basic legal protections as land animals. | Lead a coalition of the U.K.’s largest animal protection organizations to align strategy and actions to be most effective. | Joint lobbying efforts resonate with policy-makers and industry groups, ensuring the credibility of the coalition’s legislative asks.
Open information sharing amongst NGOs leads to greater understanding of opportunities and threats to our goals. |
The U.K. government takes active steps to support legislation on farmed fishes, including: positive public communication about fish; continued engagement with NGOs and industry on the topic; commissioning additional research; and the formation of government working groups to develop legislation (in addition to existing groups such as the Salmon Working Group in Scotland and the Trout Working Group in England). | Government working groups develop legislation and collaborate with the coalition on the desired outcome.
The U.K. sets the gold standard for other countries to follow in terms of fish welfare legislation at the time of slaughter. The U.K. government and public understanding of fish welfare increases, paving the way for future reforms. |
Farmed fishes experience less suffering |
| Regular communications and in-person meetings are held with corporate decision-makers | Decision-makers feel a building sense of political momentum behind THL’s legislative asks. | The government prioritizes decision-makers’ proposals. | |||||
| Trust is built with the salmon and trout industries to act as vocal supporters of legal protections. | Industry speaks favourably of legislation at key events and on their communication channels.
NGOs are invited by industry and government to provide feedback on proposed legislative guidance. |
Key paths 1 and 2—Global Cage-Free Eggs (direct corporate engagement and public pressure)
Using a combination of direct dialogue and public pressure, THL persuades companies globally to report their progress toward their cage-free commitments for hens’ welfare to ensure they are fulfilling them. They also pressure companies that have taken down their commitments to republish them, and encourage companies (where possible) to meet their cage-free goals ahead of schedule. By ensuring that commitments are visible, credible, and time bound, THL works to help prevent backsliding and keep cage-free commitments on track to become the industry standard worldwide.
Overall assessment
Many millions of chickens are already living cage-free because of global companies’ welfare commitments, and there is strong evidence that cage-free systems significantly improve hens’ wellbeing.1 Over 2,700 companies have committed to going cage free, and most of these commitments have already been implemented.2 With the majority of remaining commitments due to be implemented in 2025 and 2026, and with early signs of corporate backtracking, accountability work now appears particularly critical to protect both the animals and the credibility of future welfare campaigns.3 THL has a strong record here, engaging 123 companies in 2024, with persistent and productive engagement, including some that had dropped or stopped reporting commitments. Progress appears slower and more challenging in regions facing barriers such as weaker market concentration and restrictions on protests, but THL has demonstrated that significant wins are still possible in such regions, particularly with the support of the Open Wing Alliance (see section below).4
Based on our evaluation of the logical reasoning, evidence, and assumptions, we are fully convinced that persuading global companies to report progress on their cage-free commitments—by engaging them in direct dialogue and leading public pressure campaigns—can reliably lead to global companies fulfilling their commitments and millions of hens living cage-free. Our uncertainty in this verdict is low-to-moderate; while there is strong evidence supporting the effectiveness of corporate welfare outreach and THL has an impressive track record of success, there are still uncertainties around the effectiveness of such campaigns in emerging markets.
Key paths 3 and 4—Open Wing Alliance (coordination and grantmaking)
The Open Wing Alliance (OWA) is a global coalition of 80+ organizations across 70+ countries working to end the abuse of chickens worldwide. THL provides dedicated staff support in every region, helping member groups adapt global strategies to local contexts through regional calls, sub-regional coordination, and one-on-one guidance. The OWA grant program funds member organizations—particularly newer or underfunded groups—to launch or expand institutional campaigns for egg-laying hens and chickens used for meat. This model seeks to empower organizations globally to win major commitments while building knowledge, coordination, and momentum across the movement, improving the welfare of millions of chickens per year.
Overall assessment
Feedback from OWA members indicates the alliance provides substantial added value through access to resources, expert connections, coordination opportunities, and the credibility of the OWA brand.5 In 2024 alone, member groups secured 140 cage-free commitments for egg-laying hens (72 of which have already been implemented, largely formalizing existing practices and strengthening advocacy skills). OWA appears to be guided by robust decision making in its grantmaking, with processes that reward strategic and impactful campaigns. While we are less certain about the applicability of OWA’s tactics in regions where industrial agriculture is still nascent (e.g., Sub-Saharan Africa), overall, the OWA appears to be a well-run, high-potential program that strengthens the global movement and increases the likelihood of sustained corporate welfare progress.
Based on our evaluation of the logical reasoning, evidence, and assumptions, we are fully convinced that empowering member organizations and disbursing grants, as part of THL’s Open Wing Alliance program, can reliably lead to these groups securing large welfare commitments around the world, improving the welfare of millions of chickens each year. Our uncertainty in this verdict is moderate: Given the OWA’s focus on building global momentum, we expect most of the benefits to materialize in the medium term (say, the next 10–25 years), which is harder to measure, and we have uncertainties around the effectiveness of corporate campaigns in some emerging markets.
Key paths 5 and 6—U.S. Cage-Free Accountability (direct corporate engagement and public pressure)
THL works to ensure that companies in the U.S. follow through on their cage-free commitments for egg-laying hens. This includes persuading companies to regularly report progress, pressuring those that have removed commitments to reinstate them, and encouraging companies (where possible) to meet their goals ahead of schedule. Alongside direct dialogue with corporate leaders, THL mobilizes volunteers and consumers to apply public pressure through actions such as petitions, social media campaigns, and protests. These combined strategies seek to help keep companies on track to fulfill their pledges, annually resulting in millions of hens in the U.S. moving out of cages and cage free becoming the national standard.
Overall Assessment
As in the global case, millions of hens are already living cage free because of U.S. corporate commitments, but many deadlines fall in 2025–2026, creating risk of backtracking. THL engaged 129 companies in 2024, with productive outcomes: 55 entered dialogue and 22 began reporting progress, including companies that had previously lapsed. Spot checks suggest engagement is persistent and effective. The benefits of cage-free campaigns are expected to extend beyond individual commitments, helping to establish social norms and laying the groundwork for legislative change, an area THL is pursuing through its Animal Policy Alliance. However, current U.S. politics and avian flu disruptions may increase the risk of rollbacks, making accountability work both more urgent and more difficult.6
Based on our evaluation of the logical reasoning, evidence, and assumptions, we are fully convinced that persuading companies to report progress on their cage-free commitments, by engaging them in direct dialogue and leading public pressure campaigns, can reliably lead to U.S. companies fulfilling their commitments and millions more hens living cage free each year. Our uncertainty in this verdict is low-to-moderate: While there is strong evidence supporting the effectiveness of corporate welfare outreach and THL has an impressive track record of success, there are still some uncertainties given the unpredictability of corporate behavior in the current U.S. political climate.
Additional considerations
Key overarching assumptions and risks
- While we focused predominantly on THL’s cage-free eggs work, given this is currently where they spend most of their funding, THL also conducts outreach focused on the welfare of chickens killed for meat, primarily through the Open Wing Alliance and their corporate and policy outreach in the U.K. While their U.K. team appears to be making promising progress in this area, we expect that such work will be particularly challenging in emerging markets, where bottlenecks such as limited supply of slow-growing breeds are likely to be particularly acute.
- Regarding the long-term impacts of THL’s corporate welfare outreach programs:
- A central question for corporate welfare outreach is whether its long-term effects are positive. In the short term, these campaigns can secure meaningful reforms, but the deeper issue is whether they ultimately help dismantle factory farming or risk entrenching it.
- On the positive side, corporate commitments can shift industry norms by making higher-welfare standards expected of major retailers and producers. Over time, this “ratchet effect” helps close the gap between what the industry is already doing and what policymakers are willing to legislate, making stronger laws more likely. Cage-free state legislation in the U.S. and the E.U.’s previous proposed legislation banning cages have been cited as specific examples of this, both in the evidence we reviewed and in discussions with external experts.789
- Evidence (albeit limited) and companies’ own resistance to welfare reforms suggest that these reforms tend to impose costs on producers (e.g., through housing conversions or the purchase of slower-growing breeds), which may reduce the appeal of intensive farming and limit its future growth.10
- Campaigns also sustain public and media attention on animal welfare, equipping the movement with skills, relationships, and momentum that carry over into the next wave of reforms.11
- One main counterargument is the risk of complacency. If consumers believe “humane” labels mean problems are solved, this could reduce pressure for more ambitious change. Similarly, companies sometimes exploit reforms for positive PR while only partially improving conditions. However, concerns about complacency seem likely to be overstated—especially given how high current levels of consumer complacency already are. We consider it more plausible that reforms slightly reduce complacency by drawing attention to welfare problems rather than reinforcing them. This is also supported by the limited empirical evidence on this topic.12
- In addition, there are real risks of backsliding even after reforms are implemented. Economic downturns or supply shocks could push companies to cut corners; worsening environmental pressures could fuel arguments for cheaper, lower-welfare systems; bankruptcies, acquisitions, or leadership changes could weaken commitments; farmers may resist higher costs and reduce supply; and industry lobbying could trigger political rollbacks. Without sustained advocacy, monitoring, and pressure, both companies and governments are more likely to let standards slip. However, we view this as emphasizing the importance of accountability work and ongoing movement pressure, rather than undermining the case for corporate reforms themselves.
- Overall, we think that the evidence and reasoning indicate corporate outreach efforts are more likely to help end the worst factory farming practices, rather than maintain them. However, their impact varies depending on the context and the organizations, and we think that it would be useful and informative for THL to explicitly highlight these risks and assumptions in their theory of change.
Risk assessment strategy
- THL described a range of risks including: ill-conceived welfare interventions leading to increased egg consumption, particularly in regions where the egg industry is not yet industrialized; pushback from consumers if reforms are perceived to increase prices; pushback if advocacy tactics are considered extreme; lawsuits led by targeted corporations; internal conflict and burnout; and authorities harming staff or volunteers participating in protests.
- THL outlined a robust risk management strategy for dealing with such risks, including specific risk training for staff, a crisis communication plan (which itself includes annual ‘crisis management’ simulation training for Senior Leadership), an annually updated internal risk register, training and resources for staff participating in protests, and a guidance document specifically dealing with high-priority legal risks.
- THL also reports collaborating with relevant third parties, including animal welfare experts (to ensure that the welfare improvements sought are proven to reduce suffering), OWA member organizations (to ensure messaging is suitably tailored to the relevant region), and advisory bodies such as the Animal Activist Legal Defense Project (to receive legal support).
- While we think that some risks remain—including the potential implications of avian flu outbreaks and the Trump administration’s regressive animal welfare policies for their U.S. accountability work—we think that THL is dealing with these in a sensible and proportionate way.
- Overall, we have no concerns about THL’s risk management strategy.
Use of empirical evidence in decision making
- THL’s programmatic teams recently researched the circumstances in their respective regions to identify important trends, which informed the five-year objectives of THL’s departments.
- THL employs animal welfare scientists and researchers who review relevant literature to ensure that THL’s animal welfare asks, and their understanding of emerging issues like avian flu, are in line with scientific research. They have conducted literature reviews, commissioned external reports, and crowdsourced data about retail outlets from volunteers to inform their programs. They also attend industry events and monitor trade publications to identify opportunities for their work.
- Based on the numerous examples that THL shared with us of the research they had conducted, commissioned, and used, we are confident that their decision making is based on sound empirical evidence.
Use of Monitoring, Evaluation, and Learning (MEL) data to inform decisions
- THL keeps a comprehensive record of the companies they’ve engaged with, the commitments they’ve secured, and the estimated number of animals impacted. They review their strategic prioritization on a quarterly basis by assessing programs against the metrics in their three-year strategic plan and annual OKRs. They conduct annual feedback surveys of OWA member organizations and have developed a training program to help OWA member organizations quantitatively estimate the impact of their own work.
- We were impressed by THL’s internal evidence gathering and record keeping, and by their commitment to using this evidence to set goals, measure impact achieved, and adapt their strategies as needed.
Strategic selection of programs to complement and support each other
- THL secures global corporate commitments by combining their influence over multinational companies with the pressure applied by OWA member groups on the companies’ local branches. The different strands of the OWA program also complement one another: The trainings help ensure that the OWA member organizations carry out effective work, and the grants enable organizations to fully implement that work and scale it up.
- External experts we consulted found this strategy of engaging companies on multiple fronts to be logical and well founded. The dual training-funding approach of the OWA also aligns with our understanding of best practice for active grantmaking.
- In the U.S. and the U.K, THL complements their corporate welfare work with legislative work to help ensure that corporate practices translate into legislative welfare improvements, thereby reducing the risk of future backsliding. The risk of backsliding is likely to be higher for welfare improvements that do not entail major infrastructure changes; e.g., it is likely to be higher for broiler chickens’ welfare improvements than for cage-free transitions for egg-laying hens.
Contribution of programs to the wider animal advocacy movement
- THL’s main contribution to the wider animal advocacy movement is through the OWA, which seeks to empower its 80+ member organizations to become more effective, well coordinated, and self-sufficient. THL also assesses OWA member organizations’ contribution to the broader movement when making their grant decisions. Based on internal feedback surveys that THL shared with us, as well as our own private conversations with several OWA member organizations, the OWA seems to bring considerable value to its members.
- While we did not assess their Animal Policy Alliance in detail, our brief assessment indicates this is likely to be a valuable contribution to the broader animal advocacy movement as well.
See e.g. Bollard & Buckland (2025) and Ro (2025)
This is based on direct feedback to ACE from several OWA members and THL’s own internal surveys of OWA members.
See e.g. Bollard & Buckland (2025) and Ro (2025)
See for example Andreyeva et al. (2010), Font-i-Furnols (2023), and Anthis (2020).
This is based on evidence (e.g. Cotra (2017)) and various discussions with external experts.
Harris et al. (2022); Anderson & Lenton (2019); Anthis (2020).
Cost Effectiveness Analysis
Cost Effectiveness Assessment
- We focused our analysis on several programs combined into two cost-effectiveness analyses (CEAs): (i) Cage-Free Accountability (U.S., global, and U.K., for commitments for egg-laying hens) and (ii) Better Chicken Commitment Accountability (U.K. and E.U., regarding broiler chickens’ welfare). We chose these programs because they collectively make up a large proportion of THL’s expenditures, and because THL had a large amount of information on these programs that we thought would help yield informative results. However, notably, attempts to quantify the counterfactual impact of corporate accountability campaigns are subject to various significant assumptions and shortcomings that limit their reliability.
- Programs 1–3: Cage-Free Accountability (U.S., Global, and U.K., for commitments for egg-laying hens)
- Our CEA indicates that this work is likely to help 11 egg-laying hens per dollar through driving a transition to cage-free systems, equating to 88 Suffering-Adjusted Days (SADs) averted per dollar (range: 17–351).
- As there is limited evidence available, very rough estimates were used for the number of years it will take companies to implement their commitments, compared to when they would have done so if not for THL’s accountability campaigning.
- Program 4: Better Chicken Commitment Accountability (U.K. and E.U., regarding broiler chickens’ welfare)
- Our CEA indicates that this work is likely to help 46 broiler chickens per dollar through driving a transition to farming systems compliant with the Better Chicken Commitment, equating to 30 SADs averted per dollar (range: 2–89).
- As above, very rough estimates were used for the number of years it will take companies to implement their commitments, compared to when they would have done so if not for THL’s accountability campaigning.
Rapid back-of-the-envelope calculations
In addition to our cost-effectiveness analyses, we also quickly modelled THL’s Open Wing Alliance program to estimate the scale of their impact under simplified, rough assumptions compared to the detailed modelling of our CEAs. Based on this, we think the OWA is likely to help in the region of two animals (averting around 14 SADs) per dollar.
This was a quick assessment based on highly speculative assumptions, so we put very little credence in the resulting SADs averted per dollar, but it gave us a degree of additional confidence in the likely impact of this program.
Financial and Future Plans
The Humane League 2025 Financials and Future Plans
Room For More Funding Assessment
Based on our assessment of their future plans, we believe that THL could spend up to $28.7 million in a highly cost-effective way annually in 2026 and 2027, and our assessment of their strategic prioritization makes us confident that they will. This is $4.4 million higher than their projected 2025 revenue. With this additional funding, they would prioritize using the money to (i) expand their Open Wing Alliance teams and (ii) expand and strengthen their U.S. teams working on cage-free accountability.
Funding Capacity
Based on our assessment of THL’s future plans, we are confident that they could effectively spend up to a total annual revenue of $28.7 million.
Organizational Health Assessment
We did not detect any decision-relevant concerns in THL’s leadership and organizational health. We positively noted that there is a suitable process in place to evaluate leadership performance, all board members are fully independent, and all policies are formally in place and shared with staff. One area of improvement would be for THL to share board meetings publicly. In the staff engagement survey, staff affirmed that THL is a welcoming, impact-oriented, professional organization with a meaningful mission, a positive and respectful work culture, work-life balance, a culture of experimentation and innovation, trust in leadership, and great benefits and fair compensation.
People, policies, and processes
THL has the necessary policies and processes in place to ensure the smooth running of its operations and the safety and wellbeing of its staff.
Leadership and board governance
About 88% of staff respondents to our engagement survey indicated that they have confidence in THL’s leadership.
We found that THL’s board mostly aligned with our understanding of best practice, though board meeting minutes are not made public.
Financial health
Fifty percent of THL’s revenue is recurring (e.g., from recurring donors or ongoing long-term grant commitments). Based on an external consultation with Scarlet Spark, we find this to be a high proportion of recurring revenue (the ideal being 25% or higher); however, the 25% target is dependent on the context for each charity, so while we have noted this information here, it did not influence our recommendation decision.
THL’s liabilities-to-assets ratio does not exceed 50%.
Staff engagement and satisfaction
THL has 139 staff members (full time, part time, and contractors). A total of 111 staff members responded to our staff engagement survey, yielding a response rate of 80%. We did not have their CEO take the survey.
The average score among our staff engagement survey questions was 4.63 (on a 1–5 scale), suggesting that, on average, staff exhibit very high engagement.
Harassment and discrimination
ACE has a separate process for receiving serious claims about harassment and discrimination, and all THL staff were made aware of this option. If staff or any party external to the organization have claims of this nature, we encourage them to read ACE’s Third-Party Whistleblower Policy and fill out our claimant form. We have received no such claims regarding The Humane League.