Animal Welfare Observatory Evaluation Supplement
Theory of Change Table
Yellow highlight = priority path to impact as identified by ACE in collaboration with AWO
| Program | Program expenses (% total expenditures) | Program description | Activities (what AWO does to create change) |
Early outcomes (the change in behavior, knowledge, or attitudes that results from AWO’s activities) |
Intermediate outcomes (the results that follow from AWO’s early outcomes) |
Final outcomes (the final steps that need to happen for AWO to have their desired impact) |
Impact (the ultimate change AWO is trying to achieve) |
| European Chicken Commitment | 40% | AWO persuades major Spanish and European retailers to adopt and implement the European Chicken Commitment (ECC) via corporate engagement, public pressure, investigations, and progress tracking. | Engage corporations to promote adoption and implementation of the ECC. | Companies understand ECC benefits and risks of non-compliance. | Companies adopt ECC commitments. | Companies transition their supply chains.
A critical mass of leading Spanish retailers and European retailers operating in Spain implement ECC or equivalent standards, driving sector-wide improvements in broiler welfare. |
Improved welfare for farmed chickens. |
| Lead public pressure campaigns (e.g., media, protests, digital actions and content), supported by investigations and footage. | Companies are aware of campaigns and media exposure pressuring them to improve their broiler chicken welfare standards.
There is increased public awareness of animal welfare issues in the food industry and the actions that different retailers are taking to address these issues. |
Companies are motivated to adopt and implement the ECC.
A larger proportion of people support AWO campaigns and demand high animal welfare standards from the industry. |
Companies follow through on their ECC commitments.
High, up-to-date welfare standards are normalised in the food industry and expected by the public. |
||||
| Support ECC implementation and public accountability. | Companies are motivated to implement their ECC commitments. | Companies adjust internal operations and apply pressure across their supply chain to implement the ECC.
Companies implement their commitments in a timely and transparent way. Companies report on their implementation progress. |
Full ECC compliance is achieved by a critical mass of leading Spanish retailers and European retailers operating in Spain that implement ECC or equivalent standards, driving sector-wide improvements in broiler welfare. | ||||
| Cage-Free Eggs | 28% | AWO uses corporate engagement and public pressure campaigns to persuade Spanish retailers to end the use of cages in egg production. They also monitor to ensure policy implementation and transparency. They lobby Spanish political groups to actively oppose the use of cages. They work with Eurogroup for Animals and the End the Cage Age coalition to put pressure on the Spanish government and MEPs to ban cages. | Engage corporations about cage-free commitments. | Companies understand the need for the cage-free transition and signal their engagement (e.g., through Memoranda of Understanding with AWO). | Companies adopt and implement cage-free policies. | Supply chain in a critical mass of leading Spanish retailers and European companies operating in Spain converts to cage-free. | |
| Lead public pressure campaigns (e.g., media, protests, digital actions and content), supported by investigations and footage. | Companies are aware of campaigns and media exposure pressuring them to move to cage-free systems.
There is increased public awareness of animal welfare issues in the food industry and the actions that different companies are taking to address these issues |
Companies are motivated to adopt and implement cage-free commitments.
A larger proportion of people support AWO’s campaigns and demand cage-free policies. |
The adoption and implementation of corporate cage-free commitments accelerate.
High, up-to-date welfare standards are normalised in the food industry and expected by the public. |
||||
| Engage Spanish and E.U.-level policymakers to ban cages. | Political decision-makers understand the importance and feasibility of introducing bans on the use of caged hens. | Political support for banning cages grows as a majority of MEPs and key Spanish political actors incorporate the issue into political programs and legislative proposals. They introduce amendments or support texts aligned with cage-free objectives, and are willing to vote in favor when legislation reaches the final stage. | Legislation bans cages in Spain and the E.U. | ||||
| Farmed Aquatic Animal Welfare | 31% | AWO persuades producers and retailers to adopt stunning practices for farmed fish and to co-develop fish welfare guidelines. This is achieved through corporate engagement, public advocacy, and institutional outreach. AWO advocates for humane slaughter laws and is engaging the Spanish Government on the need to phase out ice slurry as a method of slaughter. The organization participates in E.U.-level advocacy, including direct engagement with Members of European Parliament (MEPs) and alliances with key stakeholders. | Engage in direct dialogue with retailers and producers to persuade them to adopt stunning practices and other welfare improvements for the fish in their supply chains (e.g., staff training on fish welfare, water quality, stocking density, and transport conditions). | Retailers and producers understand stunning practices and the rationale for introducing them. | Retailers and producers commit to higher welfare standards for the fishes in their sourcing and supply chains. | Producers implement effective stunning at scale. | Farmed fishes experience reduced suffering. |
| Develop policy briefs and secure meetings with government officials. | Government officials recognize farmed fish welfare issues and understand the importance of addressing them. | Spanish Government commits to introducing legislation mandating humane stunning and slaughter methods. | Stunning required by law in Spain. | ||||
| Engage MEPs on the need for robust farmed fish welfare requirements across the E.U. | MEPs place fish welfare on the political agenda by incorporating fish welfare into their public discourse and legislative work, raising the issue in speeches, and submitting official questions to the European Commission or Council on fish welfare. | Legislative support for fish protection grows: Fish welfare provisions are incorporated into political programs and legislative proposals; MEPs contribute by introducing targeted amendments to strengthen the European Commission’s draft texts or by supporting them without changes; and a majority of MEPs are willing to vote in favor of adopting final legislation. | Binding fish welfare legislation is introduced, implemented, and enforced at the E.U. level. | ||||
| Lead corporate and public campaigns to improve shrimp welfare.
(This is a new AWO initiative that had not started at the time of ACE’s evaluation, so it is not highlighted as a key path to impact.) |
Spanish consumers understand the welfare issues affecting shrimps and participate in public actions demanding improvements.
Retailers and producers agree to meet and engage in discussions about shrimp welfare. |
Retailers and producers feel public pressure and become aware of shrimp welfare concerns.
Retailers and producers are motivated to adopt welfare commitments and collaborate with AWO to define shrimp welfare standards. |
Retailers and producers implement shrimp welfare improvements across their supply chains. | Farmed shrimps and other crustaceans experience reduced suffering. |
Key paths 1 and 2—European Chicken Commitment (public pressure and direct corporate engagement)
Using a combination of direct engagement and public pressure, AWO persuades major Spanish and European retailers to adopt and implement the European Chicken Commitment (ECC), also known more broadly as the Better Chicken Commitment (BCC), which is the leading set of welfare standards for chickens used for meat. They use investigations and media outreach to build public pressure for stronger chicken welfare standards, while also working directly with companies to secure commitments, and AWO supports implementation. By ensuring that commitments are credible and holding companies accountable, AWO seeks to prevent backsliding and drive the transition toward ECC standards across supply chains, leading to higher welfare for millions of chickens per year.
Overall assessment
There is strong evidence that successfully implemented ECC standards significantly improve chickens’ welfare, with the benefits outweighing the negatives, such as slower-growing breeds needing to endure longer lifespans.1 AWO has played a major role in securing ECC commitments from six of Spain’s 10 largest retailers and engaged with all of them in 2024 with persistent and productive outreach. Notably, AWO also played a key role in Lidl Germany’s ECC commitment, estimated to affect over 50 million chickens annually once implemented. AWO’s investigations as part of this campaign have brought legal threats from Lidl, which AWO is preparing for, in consultation with legal experts.
Compliance rates with ECC asks are generally low: As of September 2025, companies had made 653 ECC welfare commitments and of these, companies were not reporting on progress for 413 (63%) of them, reporting on progress for 225 (34%) of them, and reporting only 15 (2%) of them as fulfilled.2 Public awareness and understanding of chicken welfare concerns also appear lower than for more salient welfare asks, such as cage-free commitments for egg-laying hens. Overall, however, while campaigns targeting chickens used for meat face serious challenges, AWO appears to be making significant progress and adapting their strategy in thoughtful and practical ways (e.g., by engaging with the ECC Advisory Committee and pushing for manufacturer-branded chicken to be included in the welfare commitments).
Based on our evaluation of the logical reasoning, evidence, and assumptions, we are strongly convinced that public pressure campaigns and direct corporate engagement, as part of AWO’s ECC program, will increase the likelihood of companies following through on their ECC commitments, leading to chickens experiencing higher welfare. Our uncertainty in this verdict is moderate, given our uncertainties around the broader feasibility of welfare campaigns targeting chickens killed for their meat. Furthermore, much—probably most—of the benefit of ECC campaigns will probably come from their long-term impact rather than the direct impact on the chickens in the targeted supply chains, with campaigns gradually contributing to making the ECC a social and corporate norm that then becomes enshrined in legislation. This introduces an additional element of uncertainty when assessing AWO’s ECC program.
Key path 3—Farmed Fish Welfare (direct corporate engagement)
Through direct engagement with producers and retailers, AWO works to secure the adoption of effective stunning practices and other welfare improvements for farmed fishes. While collaborating with companies to co-develop welfare guidelines and commitments, they build understanding of the rationale and benefits of stunning. By ensuring these commitments are implemented at scale, AWO seeks to reduce the suffering during slaughter and establish higher welfare standards for millions of farmed fishes.
Overall assessment
In 2024, AWO secured humane stunning commitments from Aqualande, Profand, Caviar Pirinea, and Carrefour (two of these formalized existing practices, while the others implemented new commitments). In practice, most companies have interpreted ‘humane stunning’ as ‘electrical stunning’. Evidence published earlier this year suggests that electrical stunning for species such as sea bass, sea bream, and trout may only provide marginal benefits, and in some cases could actively cause harm.3 This evidence highlights a risk that current commitments could lock in subpar—or even harmful—practices if more effective alternatives become available. AWO has been highly receptive to this new evidence, adjusting their strategy by deepening scientific engagement, working with research groups like Rethink Priorities, and beginning to explore additional welfare asks, such as stocking density reductions and enrichment opportunities. Their relationship building with the industry positions them well to continue shaping industry practices as the scientific consensus evolves: For example, they recently co-hosted the event “Fish Welfare and Sustainable Aquaculture in the Mediterranean (EMD in my Country 2025)” with APROMAR (the Spanish Aquaculture Business Association) to bring together producers, scientists, and policymakers to discuss farmed aquatic animal welfare.
Based on our evaluation of the logical reasoning, evidence, and assumptions, we are moderately convinced that direct corporate engagement within AWO’s Farmed Fish Welfare program can reliably lead to companies implementing effective stunning at scale and cause fish to experience reduced suffering at the time of slaughter, over the longer term. Our uncertainty in this verdict is moderate-to-high due to current uncertainties around the most humane stunning practices and AWO’s approach, which depends on forging relationships with aquaculture producers that will primarily yield welfare benefits over the medium term, rather than the short term.
Key path 4—Farmed Fish Welfare (engaging MEPs)
AWO engages Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) and key allies to build support for stronger welfare protections for farmed fishes. They highlight the need for robust standards at the E.U. level and work to position fish welfare as a legislative priority. By helping to secure binding E.U.-wide requirements and ensuring their implementation and enforcement, AWO seeks to reduce suffering at the time of slaughter and to establish lasting protections for millions of farmed fishes.
Overall assessment
In 2024, AWO engaged with policymakers across Spain and the E.U. through various different channels, supported by close collaboration with groups such as Eurogroup for Animals. Expert feedback suggests that achieving E.U. fish welfare reforms will be highly challenging during the current Parliament, which is currently giving low priority to animal welfare. Experts highlighted two main potential routes: pursuing asks based on existing organic standards—which AWO has not prioritized—and integrating stunning requirements into upcoming fish slaughter provisions, which aligns with AWO’s plans and will likely benefit from stronger evidence by the time legislation is implemented. At the national level, AWO’s work appears more tractable and is likely to be cost effective, given Spain’s large aquaculture sector. AWO has also made some promising progress in Spain, by co-developing voluntary fish welfare guidelines with policymakers and the industry.
Based on our evaluation of the logical reasoning, evidence, and assumptions, we are moderately convinced that engaging MEPs as part of AWO’s Farmed Fish Welfare program can reliably lead to the introduction, implementation, and enforcement of fish welfare legislation at the E.U. level. Our uncertainty in this verdict is moderate-to-high, due to the likelihood of these impacts materializing under a future E.U. Parliament, rather than the current one, making their scale harder to predict.
Key paths 5 and 6—Cage-Free Eggs (public pressure and direct corporate engagement)
Using a combination of public pressure and direct corporate engagement, AWO persuades Spanish retailers to commit to end the use of cages in egg production. They build pressure through media, investigations, and consumer actions, while also engaging companies directly to encourage their adoption and support their implementation of the cage-free systems for egg-laying hens. By ensuring that commitments are secured and followed through across supply chains, AWO seeks to accelerate the transition to cage-free systems, leading to higher welfare for millions of egg-laying hens per year.
Overall assessment
Many millions of egg-laying hens are already living cage free because of global companies’ welfare commitments, and there is strong evidence that cage-free systems significantly improve hens’ wellbeing.4 Globally, over 2,700 companies have committed to going cage free, and most of these commitments have already been implemented.5 With the majority of remaining commitments due to be implemented in 2025 and 2026, and with early signs of corporate backtracking, accountability work now appears particularly critical to protect both the animals in the supply chains and the credibility of future welfare campaigns.6 In 2024, AWO engaged 25 companies, with nine entering active dialogue, as well as broadening Grupo Día’s commitment to include a wider range of products. Our spot checks confirmed AWO’s engagement efforts to be persistent and productive, underlining their capacity to hold companies accountable to this important implementation window.
Based on our evaluation of the logical reasoning, evidence, and assumptions, we are fully convinced that public pressure campaigns and direct corporate engagement, as part of AWO’s Cage-Free Eggs program, can reliably accelerate the adoption and implementation of corporate cage-free commitments, leading to egg-laying hens experiencing higher welfare. Our uncertainty in this verdict is low-to-moderate, as there are some challenges with accurately assessing the counterfactual impact of conducting accountability work.
Additional considerations
Key overarching assumptions and risks
- A central question for corporate welfare outreach is whether its long-term effects are positive. In the short term, these campaigns can secure meaningful reforms, but the deeper issue is whether they ultimately help dismantle factory farming or risk entrenching it.
- On the positive side, corporate commitments can shift industry norms by making higher-welfare standards expected of major retailers and producers. Over time, this “ratchet effect” helps close the gap between what the industry is already doing and what policymakers are willing to legislate, making stronger laws more likely. Cage-free state legislation in the United States and the E.U.’s previously proposed legislation banning cages have been cited as specific examples of this, both in the evidence we reviewed and in discussions with external experts.789
- Evidence (albeit limited) and companies’ own resistance to welfare reforms suggest that these reforms tend to impose costs on producers (e.g., through housing conversions or the purchase of slower-growing breeds of chickens), which may reduce the appeal of intensive farming and limit its future growth.10
- Campaigns also sustain public and media attention on animal welfare, equipping the movement with skills, relationships, and momentum that carry over into the next wave of reforms.11
- One main counterargument to corporate welfare outreach is the risk of complacency: If consumers believe “humane” labels mean problems of welfare are solved, this could reduce pressure for more ambitious change. Similarly, companies sometimes exploit reforms for positive PR while only partially improving conditions. However, concerns about complacency seem likely to be overstated, especially given how high current levels of consumer complacency already are—we consider it more plausible that reforms slightly reduce complacency by drawing attention to welfare problems rather than reinforcing them. This is also supported by the limited empirical evidence on this topic.12
- In addition, there are real risks of backsliding even after reforms are implemented: Economic downturns or supply shocks could push companies to cut corners; worsening environmental pressures could fuel arguments for cheaper, lower-welfare systems; bankruptcies, acquisitions, or leadership changes could weaken commitments; farmers may resist higher costs and reduce supply; and industry lobbying could trigger political rollbacks. Without sustained advocacy, monitoring, and pressure, both companies and governments are more likely to let animal welfare standards slip. However, to us, these risks reinforce the importance of accountability work and ongoing movement pressure, rather than undermining the case for corporate reforms.
- Overall, we think that the evidence and reasoning indicate that corporate welfare outreach efforts are more likely to help end the worst factory farming practices, rather than maintain them, in the long term.13 However, this seems likely to vary depending on the context and the organizations, and we think that it would be useful and informative for AWO to foreground these risks and assumptions more explicitly in their theory of change.
Risk assessment strategy
- AWO described a range of risks to their work, including: reputational backlash to investigations and campaigns; national work displacing supply chains to countries with lower welfare standards; companies undermining the credibility of welfare commitments through tokenistic or partial compliance; staff or collaborators being exposed to legal risks as a result of their work; lack of coordination with others in the movement, leading to contradictory and ineffective messaging; and legislative changes reducing the impact of campaigns.
- AWO currently uses an informal risk management process. AWO reports that senior leadership and operations staff regularly assess emerging risks (especially those related to legal exposure, financial stability, and reputational impact) and respond with mitigation plans as needed.
- We think it is best practice for organizations to have a more formal risk management process, so it is promising that AWO is in the process of introducing a more formal system. They are developing a formal risk compliance system to identify, monitor, and respond to organizational risks, including an internal risk matrix, documentation protocols, and regular assessments of legal, operational, and reputational risks.
- Overall, we have no concerns about AWO’s risk management strategy.
Use of empirical evidence in decision making
- AWO’s decision making appears to be well grounded in empirical evidence. For example, their decision to launch a fish welfare program was informed by scientific literature, reports by the European Food Safety Authority, meetings with experts, and a report they commissioned from external researchers. Likewise, after becoming aware of evidence suggesting that the electrical stunning of sea bass, sea bream, and some other major fish species may not be as effective as previously thought, AWO amended their approach accordingly. They also refer to frameworks such as the Welfare Footprint Institute’s welfare impact quantifications14.
- For campaigns, they regularly conduct A/B testing and other trials to inform their messaging, and they have worked with Campaigns Lab to improve and pilot new approaches.
- We think it is highly positive that AWO appeared to rapidly incorporate significant new evidence into their campaigns. For example, we spoke to a researcher involved with the electrical stunning findings who reported that AWO appeared impressively engaged with the research and open to adjusting their approaches based on the findings.
Use of Monitoring, Evaluation, and Learning (MEL) data to inform decisions
- AWO keeps a record of the companies they have engaged, including the estimated number of animals impacted (which they calculate using a tool created by Rethink Priorities for fish, and a combination of industry reports, self-reported corporate data, and methodology in line with that of The Humane League and the Open Wing Alliance for chickens). They have a set of criteria that they use for strategic decision making about how to scale up, scale down, or otherwise change their programs, but they do not currently have a standardized method for applying this. They are working with The Mission Motor to enhance their MEL, including developing shared quantitative and qualitative indicators and scoring tools to support more consistent, transparent, and evidence‐based decision making.
- We think that AWO’s record keeping of company engagement, including estimated animal numbers impacted, is impressive. We agree that it would be best practice for them to introduce a more formal process for strategic decision making, so it is promising that they are taking concrete steps to do so. Staff at The Mission Motor reported that AWO has recently made considerable improvements to their MEL processes and appears open to making strategic changes based on new evidence.
Strategic selection of programs to complement and support each other
- AWO’s three main programs (chicken welfare, egg-laying hen welfare, and fish welfare) all target relatively neglected species using similar strategies (corporate outreach, public pressure, and political advocacy). AWO reports that their campaigns targeting chickens raised for meat and egg-laying hens give them visibility that strengthens their credibility with corporations and legislators when engaging with them on fish welfare.
- AWO has a strong focus on ensuring that their corporate work translates into longer-term legislative progress, reducing the risk of future corporate backsliding. The risk of backsliding is likely to be higher for welfare improvements that do not entail major infrastructure changes; for example, it is likely to be higher for broiler chickens’ welfare improvements than for cage-free transitions for egg-laying hens.
- Recently, this has been a particular focus for their fish welfare campaign, as detailed above. In 2024, they also had 10 meetings with Spanish and E.U. policymakers to discuss the need to end the use of cages for farmed animals, and submitted two parliamentary questions to this end. For chickens used for meat, policy work was deemed less of a priority in 2024 in favor of other programs.
- While AWO does appear to carefully consider their choice of programs, we have minor concerns that they are trying to cover too broad a range of programs, which might reduce their capacity to maintain long-term continued pressure on target companies and policy makers.
Contribution of programs to the wider animal advocacy movement
- AWO reports collaborating with other organizations directly and through various alliances (such as Eurogroup for Animals, the Open Wing Alliance, the Aquatic Animal Alliance, and the End the Cage Age coalition) by sharing plans and updates, contributing to shared messaging, and seeking alignment before launching public campaigns.
- We spoke with staff at Eurogroup for Animals and several other organizations that AWO had worked with, who reported them to be highly proactive and collaborative.
See, e.g., Saraiva et al. (2024) and Schuck-Paim et al. (2025)
See e.g. Bollard & Buckland (2025) and Ro (2025)
See for example Andreyeva et al. (2010), Font-i-Furnols (2023), and Anthis (2020).
This is based on evidence (e.g. Cotra (2017)) and various discussions with external experts.
Harris et al. (2022); Anderson & Lenton (2019); Anthis (2020)
Learn more about the Welfare Footprint Institute’s welfare impact qualifications at: https://welfarefootprint.org/
Cost Effectiveness Analysis
Animal Welfare Observatory 2025 CEA
Cost Effectiveness Assessment
- We focused our analysis on two programs: (i) AWO’s European Chicken Commitment program and (ii) their Cage-Free Eggs program. We chose these programs because they collectively make up a large proportion of AWO’s expenditures and because AWO had a large amount of information on these programs that we thought would help yield informative results. However, attempts to quantify the counterfactual impact of corporate accountability campaigns are subject to various significant assumptions and shortcomings that limit their reliability.
- Program 1: European Chicken Commitment
- Our CEA indicates that this work is likely to help 48 chickens per dollar through driving a transition to improved welfare standards for chickens used for meat, equating to 30 Suffering-Adjusted Days (SADs) averted per dollar (range: 4–126).
- Attempts to quantify the counterfactual impact of corporate accountability campaigns were subject to various significant assumptions and shortcomings that limit their reliability. For example, the figures indicating when companies will implement their commitments, compared to when they would have done so if not for AWO’s accountability campaigning, were very rough estimates based on the limited evidence available.
- Program 2: Cage-Free Eggs
- Our CEA indicates that this work is likely to help eight laying hens per dollar through driving a transition to cage-free systems, equating to 26 SADs averted per dollar (range: 8–67).
- Attempts to quantify the counterfactual impact of corporate accountability campaigns were subject to various significant assumptions and shortcomings that limit their reliability. For example, as with the European Chicken Commitment program, the figures indicating when companies will implement their commitments, compared to when they would have done so if not for AWO’s accountability campaigning, were very rough estimates based on the limited evidence available.
Rapid back-of-the-envelope calculations
In addition to our cost-effectiveness analyses, we also quickly modeled some of AWO’s other programs to estimate the order of magnitude of their impact under simplified, rough assumptions compared to the more detailed modeling of our CEAs:
- E.U. Farmed Fish Welfare Policy: approximately 309 fishes helped and 15 SADs averted per dollar
- Spanish Farmed Fish Welfare Policy: approximately 70 fishes helped and 3 SADs averted per dollar
- Shrimp Advocacy: approximately 159 shrimps helped and 1 SAD averted per dollar
- Laying Hen Cage-Free Ban Advocacy: approximately 71 hens helped and 215 SADs averted per dollar
These were quick assessments based on uncertain assumptions, so we put very little credence in the specific SADs averted per dollar figures, but they gave us a degree of additional confidence in the likely impact of these programs.
Financial and Future Plans
Animal Welfare Observatory 2025 Financials and Future Plans
Room For More Funding Assessment
Based on our assessment of their future plans, we believe that AWO could spend up to approximately $2.5 million in a highly cost-effective way annually in 2026 and 2027, and our assessment of their strategic prioritization makes us confident that they will. This is approximately $700k higher than their projected 2025 revenue. With this additional funding, they would prioritize strengthening accountability work on aquatic animals, chickens used for meat, and cage-free hens through investigations and public progress tracking. They also plan to launch a shrimp welfare campaign, combining corporate outreach, investigations, and public awareness. Beyond program growth, AWO aims to improve internal systems, expand E.U. advocacy, and invest in communications and fundraising to build public trust.
Funding Capacity
Based on our assessment of AWO’s future plans, we are confident that they could effectively spend up to a total annual revenue of $2.9 million.
Organizational Health Assessment
We did not detect any decision-relevant concerns in AWO’s leadership and organizational health. We positively noted that there is a suitable process in place to evaluate leadership performance, all board members are fully independent (as a policy), and all essential policies are either fully or partially in place and shared with staff. One area for improvement would be to formalize the policies that are currently partial or informal. In the staff engagement survey, staff affirmed that they feel safe and comfortable at work, they trust the organization, the founder’s stepping down was handled well, leadership is empathetic and welcoming, and they enjoy the flexible work environment.
People, policies, and processes
Animal Welfare Observatory has the necessary policies and processes in place to ensure the smooth running of its operations and the safety and wellbeing of its staff.
Leadership and board governance
95% of staff respondents to our engagement survey indicated that they have confidence in AWO’s leadership.
We found that the AWOs board mostly aligns with our understanding of best practice. Ideally, a formal conflict of interest policy will be adopted in the future.
Financial health
2.8% of AWO’s revenue is recurring (e.g. from recurring donors or ongoing long-term grant commitments). Based on an external consultation with Scarlet Spark, we find this to be a low proportion of recurring revenue (the ideal being 25% or higher); however, the 25% target is dependent on the context for each charity, so while we have noted this information here, it did not influence our recommendation decision.
AWO’s liabilities-to-assets ratio does not exceed 50%.
Staff engagement and satisfaction
AWO has 23 staff members (full time, part time, and contractors). Twenty-one staff members responded to our staff engagement survey, yielding a response rate of 91%—we did not have their Executive Director take the survey. The average score among our staff engagement survey questions was 4.78 (on a 1–5 scale), suggesting that, on average, staff exhibit very high engagement.
Harassment and discrimination
ACE has a separate process for receiving serious claims about harassment and discrimination, and all AWO staff were made aware of this option. If staff or any party external to the organization has claims of this nature, we encourage them to read ACE’s Third-Party Whistleblower Policy and fill out our claimant form. We have received no such claims regarding Animal Welfare Observatory.